toonpool logo

Enjoy the World of Cartoons

 (143476)

User Pass

Enregistrer Aide 
 Pro Search 
js-cookie-warning
français select language
[X]
english english
français français
deutsch deutsch
nederlands nederlands
español español
türkçe türkçe
Ελληνικά Ελληνικά
italiano italiano
NEWS:
  • The Ecstatic Line: The Drawings of Hermé
  • ++++
  • Interview mit Kai Diekmann
  • Cartoons
  • Boutique
  • Collections
  • Forum
  • Communauté
  • Toon Agent
↑ top
Cartoon: Ahmadinazist (medium) by rodrigo tagged ahmadinejad,president,iran,israel,nazi,hitler,racism,summit,un,united,nations

Ahmadinazist



Agrandir le motif | Envoyer comme e-Card Tweet




4 Commentaires


 


Guest
im not german so i dont get this

Anon (212.219.231.1), au 18. mars 2010  [aviser]  [citer]  [repondre]

 
Peter Russel
Member
Maybe we should write a standard disclaimer on this topic .. this came up a couple of times already.
It is a pretty German feat to react strongly to any cartoon that claims that someone is "a Hitler". And I agree. I am German, after all. The horrors of Nazi Germany are a complex topic, and any simple equation with Hitler/Nazis does not help to understand either National Socialism or the person / country /animal thus equated with it. Sometimes, however, the "German reactions" mentioned above seem standardized, or even as if we want to protect our Hitler from any comparisons with your small-time villains (this is not directed at Art Holland). This, too, is a serious issue and we (or anyone else reacting that way) should be careful about it. I opt for Nazi comparisons that transcend shallow nazi=evil statements and accusations of others being evil... AS LONG AS THEY ARE FUNNY. Also, I want more Hitlers in cartoons. No reason we shouldn't make fun of that man.
As for this cartoon... nah ... I don't think it's that funny. Or transcending anything. But I like the grotesque pinnocchio nose thing

Peter Russel, au 13. mai 2009  [aviser]  [citer]  [repondre]

 
rodrigo
Member
Hi Art. A caricature is a portrait that exaggerates or distorts the essence of a person or thing. It uses exaggeration of some characteristics and oversimplification of others. And a cartoon is a sort of a caricature of a viewpoint or situation. When you are used to this language, you expect just that. There's nothig wrong by comparing someone to Hitler or Stalin, provided that everybody know what these two where able to do (in this case is even more appropriated, cause it seems that Ahmadinejad doesn't know). Don't think most of the people would do the exercise you did to read in this cartoon the message that Hitler was a nice guy, instead of that Ahmadinejad is probably not that nice.

But there's nothing wrong with discussing that. It's actually interesting to reflect about it. Thanks for the opportunity.

rodrigo, au 27. avril 2009  [aviser]  [citer]  [repondre]

 
Art Holland
Member
Ahmadinejad is an ugly ant-Semite. But to compare him with Hitler trivializes the nazi-crimes. There is no difference to other painters who combine Israel with the Fascists.

Art Holland, au 27. avril 2009  [aviser]  [citer]  [repondre]

 
 

Ajouter commentaires Ajouter commentaires
left Nouveaux Cartoons right
Cartoon: The firing epidemic (small) by rodrigo tagged unemployment,work,society,economy,editorial,cartoon
The firing ep...
Cartoon: Freedom of thinking (small) by rodrigo tagged porto,cartoon,oporto,portugal,festival,human,rights,prison,censorship
Freedom of t...
Cartoon: Recession is over (small) by rodrigo tagged crisis,unemployment,recession,money,europe,eu,economy,euro,financial,companies,bankers,broken,automakers,businessmen
Recession is ...


rodrigo de rodrigo
chargé au 23. avril 2009
vu 3077 fois | 4 Commentaires

Information


Published at www.expresso.pt on April 22nd, 2009
Mots-clé ahmadinejad president iran israel nazi hitler racism summit un united nations
Style Dessin de couleur
Catégorie Politique
rating-star
Applause
14
ecard
e-Card
favorite
Favori
report spam
Spam
e-Card
Vous aimez ce Cartoon et voulez le montrer à vos amis? Envoyez un e-Card! [fermer]
Spam
Vous pensez que ce motif ne s'accorde pas à toonpool.com? Un Cartoon choquant? Avertissez-nous! [fermer]

Traductions

[ajouter]

Choisir une traduction

Collections


And you, Sir, are worse than Hitler!
Dictators 2008
Why War?
toonpool.com Blog RSS Feed toonpool.com on twitter toonpool.com on facebook
Protection des données | Conditions d'utilisation | Sur nous | Contact
Copyright © 2007-2012 toonpool.com GmbH